- Field Day |
- Buildings Alive |
- Visions |
- CLGBT |
- Green Community |
- Fun & Free S#!T |
- Crossword |
- CL Space |
Wednesday, January 14, 2009
American Idol is poison
Posted by Eric Snider on Wed, Jan 14, 2009 at 4:52 PM
I watched a rented DVD of Woody Allen's Cassandra's Dream last night, a film which instantly goes into the pantheon of worst Woody flicks ever.
But that's not the point of this post. The point is ... I was not watching American Idol. When it comes to that wretched spectacle, I'm a conscientious objector. I find the show, the very idea of the show, abhorrent. If I had last night to do over again, I would watch neither, but given the choice between just the two, I would stick with Cassandra's Dream.
OK, I'm not the first Idol hater out there. But I've never spoken up before, and with the program in its eighth season, I realized I got some shit to say. I've watched a few episodes, mostly partial episodes, over the years, so feel qualified to comment. (Hell, I would've anyway.)
My beef with Idol is not the circus atmosphere; the wacky (Abdul) or cruel (Cowell) judges; or the gimmicky device early in the season of showing the tone-deaf hacks, which I've always suspected are plants (I understand Idol has backed off showing those clowns a bit). It's not even so much that even the good singers come from a cookie-cutter mold of safe, vaguely soul-oriented music (I read that one girl performed "Sittin' on the Dock of the Bay" last night).
It's that American Idol is a creativity killer. The show is the quickest avenue to pop stardom, and it has a disproportionate influence defining American mainstream music. As they say, we reap what we sow. In this case, bland, bland, bland. Same, same, same. If there were a program where singer/songwriters performed their own music in a contest format, and the judges used creativity as a criterion, I'd give it a look-see. (Who knows; there may have already been one that failed.)
Certainly some of Idol's late-round contestants have singing chops, but I've never seen an ounce of originality from them. They know the drill, the follow the blueprint.
I can't really blame Cowell and the rest for cashing in on such a lasting phenomenon. It's really the public's fault. The masses are allowing themselves to be manipulated and dumbed down. The rest of us, those of us with some taste, reject the show as glitzy karaoke (or watch it as camp).
Some of you may now be thinking: Oh jeez, the rantings of an elitist music critic. There may be a little truth to that. (Let me add, though, that I've always liked a lot of mainstream stuff.) Still, I resolutely believe that American Idol is a destructive, or at least stagnating, force in American, make that global, pop music. Those of us with a conscience should refuse to watch. It just may help the show go away quicker.
Comments (43)
Showing 1-43 of 43
Eric, I agree, but do you slow down when you pass a car crash, even if you're not driving? These first episodes are so gut wrenching, people's "dreams" flushed by these judges. The contestants are so vulnerable and naive, I'm laughing and feeling so bad for them at the same time - it's really something else.
like
dislike
i think the most fascinating issues about american idol have to do with what we value as "skill" or "talent" in our current society. creativity and originality (whatever that word means) get second or third billing to ACCURACY OF REPRODUCTION. singing accurately is just not that great of a skill. certainly not worth informing our entire cultural output. but i don't watch tv, so i don't know what i'm talking about.
Good post, I can’t say that I agree with everything that was said, but very good information overall:) -----
We have been banned and have a considerable amount of money owed to us. http://www.anfworld.com/abercrombie-and-fitch-jeans.html http://www.anfworld.com/ruehl-no-925.html
Thank you for displaying us how to create these stunning stars - I really like them! I just built my initial one particular right away! Your recommendations are extremely uncomplicated to recognize! Posed By Jordan Retro 8
Hi there, I found your blog via Google while searching for first aid for a heart attack and your post looks very interesting for me.
Thanks for your great website, it is very good. Welcome to visit our website at anytime!
Youth will not be a time of existence; it is known as a state of thoughts. It is just not a matter of rosy cheeks, red lips and supple knees. Did you concur with me? Posed By new Jordans
Thanks for sharing your great website with us. i am really love it. Welcome to visit our website at anytime too.
God assist individuals who allow on their own. Arrive on all people and permit God witness your progress from every last factors! Allow the unpleasant affair go. Posed By Jordan Spizike
It really is pleasure to find out you, wishing the nicest issues generally to suit your needs, not merely nowadays, but every one of the 12 months by way of given that you may be seriously a delight to understand. Posed By Jordan 9
Thanks for sharing your great website with us. i am really love it. I Knew many knowledge from it.
Thanks for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it. I put a link to my site to here so other people can read it. My readers have about the same interets
An intention in existence could be the only lot of money well worth acquiring. Pursue your object, be it what it can, steadily and indefatigably. Guy who features a settled goal will certainly be successful. Posed By Jordan Spizike
dear friend, thank you for sharing your great website with us, i love it very much.
femme moncler vestes en duvet sacs moncler un certain nombre de marques internationales de cosmétiques
fendi handbags We will always provide good quality,good pricePolo t-shirts or you.
www.pickyourpop.com is Best supplier for the Fashion products, We can provide CheapOakey Sunglasses ,
order today and get free shipping abercrombie & fitch clothings are on sale now. welcome to discount Abercrombie & fitch.
order today and get free shipping more and more classic or fashion A & F clothings are on sale. welcome to buy.
If I never met you, I wouldn't like you. If I didn't like you, I wouldn't love you. If I didn't love you, I wouldn't miss you. But I did, I do, and I will.
Looking for Abercrombie & Fitch Outlet Stores? buy cheap abercrombie and fitch clothes?our site will be your best choice.welcome to our Abercrombie & Fitch online UK store ,there have best Abercrombie and Fitch clothes,please click the title or name enterd. http://www.abercrombie-clearance.net/
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about information and love learning more on this. If possible, as you gain expertise, It is extremely helpful for me. would you mind updating your blog with more information
Thank you for sharing your great website with us. it is so great. and welcome to visit our http://www.nfls.cc too.
The Coach handbags are from the latest release of Coach Designer bags. Their crisp, scribble material, leather handle, perfectly complements the relaxed shape of this stylish pouch. The Coach handbag fits all of your essentials and more http://www.ebayond.com
Author Archives
-
Concert review: Richard Thompson at Tampa Theatre 1
The British musician offered up an evening full of jaw-dropping guitartistry at his Feb. 3 show.
-
Liam Neeson battles nature in The Grey
Guess who wins.
- More »
