Thursday, March 11, 2010

Movie Review of Judd Apatow wannabee She's Out of My League, starring Jay Baruchel, Alice Eve, T.J. Miller, Jessica St. Clair and Lindsay Sloane

Posted by Rabid Nick Refer on Thu, Mar 11, 2010 at 6:00 AM

[Editor's Note: She's Out of My League opens Fri., March 12 at area theaters. (You can check showtimes here.) For more reviews of the biggest new releases, check out the Daily Loaf Movie Review Index.]

SHE

There are times when awkward situations are dazzling to the eye. You don’t really want to look, but somehow you’re still compelled to do so. She’s Out of My League is not one of those situations. What we have here is another lazy attempt at emulating a Judd Apatow movie. That's bad, but not nearly as egregious as just being plain unfunny. And failed attempts at humor are what She's Out Of My League succeeds at best.

She’s Out of My League is a typical fish-out-of-water tale about a rather unseemly nerd (Knocked Up’s Jay Baruchel) who finds himself all atwitter after a fateful encounter with a gorgeous woman (newcomer Alice Eve) who exemplifies the film’s title. Not only does the knockout give him the time of day, she actually expresses interest in the lad — which quickly leads to a series of uncomfortable scenes. Can the boy who only ranks a “five” successfully land a “hard 10”? And more important: If he does, will we really even care?

click to enlarge league2
Sadly, the answer is a resounding no. She’s Out of My League tries hard to be a witty Judd Apatow movie but fails to be anything other than an uninspired clone. In order for the unnatural romance between the leads to be the slightest bit believable, a certain amount of chemistry needed to be apparent between Baruchel and Eve. There is exactly none. Piss-poor casting made this unavoidable. I’m sorry, but Baruchel brings nothing to the table that would allow me to suspend my disbelief enough to fall for this scripted happenstance. A better choice would likely have been Apatow lap-dog Seth Rogen, but Judd already made that movie.

Laughs are few and far between during the film’s 105-minute running time. There's one scene involving male body hair removal that elicited uproarious laughter from those in attendance, but it again left me longing for a film I’d already seen. The supporting cast, including T.J.Miller (Cloverfield) and Best Week Ever regular Jessica St. Clair, do their best to inflate the popped balloon that is the film's humor, but they can't blow life into this tepid endeavor.

She’s Out of My League is a “four” desperately trying to catch the “10” of, say, Knocked Up. There is an absence of heart, an absence of humor, and an absence of creativity that will leave you cold. The movie has decent enough intentions, but it just doesn't come through as promised. It might be worth a rental, but I wouldn’t advise you rush to the theaters this weekend. Instead, stay home and watch your favorite Judd Apatow movies. That’s what She's Out of My League will leave you longing to do, anyway.

Become a fan of  The Rabid One at

RabidNick.com

and

Follow him on his Twitter feed

for more posts and assorted shenanigans.

It's totally a 10.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Daily Loaf

Author Archives

Search Events

Recent Comments

© 2012 SouthComm, Inc.