Thursday, October 22, 2009
CD review: The Flaming Lips, Embryonic
Posted by Eric Snider on Thu, Oct 22, 2009 at 2:22 PM
The quest for free, unfettered creativity can sometimes lead straight over a cliff. And so The Flaming Lips crash and burn with Embryonic (Warner Bros.), a noisy, tuneless “double” album (on one CD) that falls prey to all manner of sophomoric excess and discards the techno-psychedelic-dream-pop that the band brought to sublime fruition with 2006’s At War with the Mystics.
The unfettered freedom bit is not simply my interpretation. In an eloquent essay that’s more interesting and entertaining than the 70 minutes of music it came with, leader Wayne Coyne documents the band’s goal to strip the creative process of filters, premeditation and fear. “So, yes, more free!!! Now at last to be free from the discipline and focus. Free to fail … free to lose ourselves,” he writes.
Indeed.
The tracks are mostly culled from crude jams built around the incessant clatter of two or more drummers, which renders the grooves sloppy and random and denudes the music of the Lips’ trademark gentle naivete. Worse, though: Of Embryonic’s 18 selections, there’s hardly a legitimate pop song to be heard. When Coyne and Co. do stumble upon something vaguely melodic – like the warmly pleasing “The Impulse” – the vocal is barely discernible amid heavy robotic effects.
In fact, Coyne’s fragile falsetto, so effective when soaring over trippy sound collages on the best Lips stuff, is either smothered in the mix or doctored with so many computerized effects as to void it of humanity.
In his essay, Coyne writes that “double albums usually fall into a couple of categories … indulgent, egotistical or lazy.” All three apply to Embryonic, especially the first two.
He continues, “We wanted to be more free … the freedom without the discipline or restraint. Fuck yeah … Either way it’s too late … the damage has been done.”
True. True.
Latest in Daily Loaf
-
Prosecutor finds probable cause that Jim Norman violated state ethics law
Norman and his attorney are calling the ruling a victory.
-
NPR's "All Things Considered" to feature Asolo's Yentl tomorrow at 5 p.m.
NPR will run an exclusive interview with singer-songwriter and Yentl composer Jill Sobule as well as exclusive song recordings from Asolo Repertory's Yentl tomorrow, Sat., Feb. 4, at 5 p.m.
-
Komen for the Cure blinks; restores grants to Planned Parenthood
In a surprising retreat, Susan G. Komen for the Cure has apologized for their recent decision to stop funding breast cancer screenings through Planned Parenthood.
- More »
Author Archives
Top Commenters
Comments (0)