As someone whose formative years were profoundly influenced by The Beatles, I just assumed that their music was so indelibly etched in my consciousness that I would never hear it in a new way. The songs all of them, or nearly had taken on such a mythic quality that spinning them every so often and letting their magnificence wash over me would do just fine. (Pictured: The Beatles circa 1967, (c) Apple Corps Ltd 2009.)
Then on 9.09.09 came the remastered catalogue 22 years after the initial CD issue and an opportunity for a new perspective. I was sorely tempted to plunk down the 200-some bucks for the boxed set, but ultimately found the purchase a bit too dear, so Ive vowed to scrimp and save and acquire as many of the 14 individual CDs as I can.
Which titles to start with is a source of great debate among Beatles devotees, but for me it was easy: Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band and Revolver. (Pepper wins as my favorite in a photo finish.) I was excited, of course, about the chance to hear Getting Better, And Your Bird Can Sing, Lovely Rita, She Said She Said, Good Morning Good Morning, Tomorrow Never Knows et al in crisp new sonic dimensions that took an elite group of engineers four years to accomplish.
But I didnt expect a revelation.
After purchasing the discs, I whetted my appetite in a stock car stereo, but it wasnt until I slipped Sgt. Pepper into my NAD CD player, adjusted the volume on my beast of a Sony receiver, ran it through my B&W tower speakers and grabbed the sweet spot on the couch that the amazement commenced.
Damn if I wasnt hearing Beatles music in a new way. Its not as simple as discovering fresh details, like the way hand percussion shakers, tambourines and the like gives the songs enhanced rhythmic propulsion; or how a bass harmonica fattens the low end of Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite; or how the string quartet on Eleanor Rigby reveals its component parts (dig the deep cello in the left channel).
Its more than that: The remasters humanize the music.
Hows that, you say? Hasnt the Beatles music always been valued for its humanity? Of course, but Im talking about something different: the way the new versions provide a vivid reminder that humans actually made this music. It occurred to me that I had only heard Fab Four songs in more visceral circumstances: on transistor radios or a cheap record player as a kid; on crappy stereos in dorms and apartments as a young adult; in the car or as background party music as a grownup.
Sitting in the dark on the couch, it dawned on me: I hadnt really listened to the Beatles in decades.
So the next day I pulled the original 87 discs from the shelf and played them through the same stereo system. Yes, they are compressed and short on nuance in comparison to the remasters, but in no way are theyre lousy (which has been the accepted take on the early CDs over the last couple of decades).
The new versions were actually a bit unsettling at first. Because of all their sonic specifics, they downplayed some of the musics majesty, made me constantly aware that a group of exceptionally talented musicians at a particular place and time pooled their resources and succeeded beyond all expectation. Rather than heaven sent, Pepper and Revolver were the product of intense creativity. And painstaking work. OK, maybe a bit of the divine as well.
So the new CDs demythologize the music some. I was hoping for a new perspective and I got one.
Over several days of hyper-focused listening, I marveled at the consistent rightness of the aesthetic decisions, which is to warn you that we are now entering the geek portion of this article:
During the tape-loop calliope segment of Mr. Kite, a simple, wheezing organ plays the melody underneath, keeping the song grounded.
In the string section of Shes Leaving Home (one of the Pepper tracks I most neglected), staccato chirps counter the sweeping lines, adding to the tunes quiet turmoil. And Id not previously registered how McCartneys vocals so exquisitely evokes regret and sadness.
On Good Morning Good Morning, the acerbic reed section is relegated to the right channel and pushed back in the mix, which sets the stage for the rambunctious power of the guitar solo.
As the first string crescendo in A Day in the Life gives way to the peppy McCartney section (woke up, got out of bed) Ringo taps four beats to the bar on the snare drum, accentuating the galloping rhythm.
The ramshackle acoustic guitar on Im Only Sleeping helps give the song its slacker vibe.
The rhythm track of Here There and Everywhere relies on little more than muted drums, bass and a simple electric guitar chords, allowing the lush vocal arrangement to carry the tune.
A low-register boogie piano adds to the bounce of Good Day Sunshine.
The Carl Perkins-esque, early Beatles twang on the verses of Dr. Robert is countered by a spacey bridge (Well, well, well, youre feeling fine) anchored by a droning organ. And on the chorus harmonies, I love McCartneys bluesy shout as a counterpart of Lennons nasality.
An aggressive, four-square tambourine part on Got to Get You Into My Life, which sounds as if its coming from a center channel, gives the groove extra heft.
Suffice to say I could go on. And on.
In closing, let me pass along a tip that would seem obvious. Id only recommend acquiring the remasters if you have a credible hi-fi system. During my Beatles vigil, I invited a couple of fellow travelers over for listening sessions. One of them, who already had the boxed set on order, said, Oh shit, now Ive got to buy a stereo.
To find out more about this weekend's WMNF Beatles Tribute, click here; to read more about Rock Band: The Beatles, click here.
The Beatles Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band from Yellow Submarine.
And "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds"
Comments (0)