I recently read Michael Pollan's impassioned (and alarming) book, The Omnivore's Dilemma, that explores "our national eating disorder." It's difficult to be a proud carnivore (or a fast food eater) after reading it but somehow I didn't plunge headfirst into a vat of vegetarianism. In one section, Pollan insightfully reports about the deplorable living conditions of factory-churned, corn-fed cattle, so shortly after reading it, I earnestly sought out humanely-raised, grass-fed meat. I figured if I was going to continue to assert homo sapien's food-chain dominance, I can at least do it with a clear conscience.
Essentially, grass-fed means the cattle are born, raised and harvested to meet USDA Approved Grass-fed Protocol. This edict forbids the use of artificial hormones, confinement feeding, animal by-products and antibiotics. Turns out, there's not a helluva lot of places you can buy grass-fed beef in Tampa Bay. In fact, I only uncovered one reliable place: Whole Foods. And Mark Malowski, Meat Team Leader at the Tampa location, reports their three-month-old grass-fed beef program is booming. So much so, it sells out the day it arrives (Monday).
Whole Foods -- which has locally-sourced meat programs all over the U.S. -- buys their beef from White Oak Pastures on the Florida-Georgia border, where the Harris Family has raised cattle since 1866. Their official certifications range from Certified Organic to Certified Humane and the "plant" is run by an artisan meat cutter.
Scott Chansky, Regional Meat Coordinator for Whole Foods, has been in the beef biz at this natural foods grocery store chain ten years. He sees two reasons for the shift to grass-fed: health and the impact on the environment. Grass-fed farmers don't spread pesticides on their grazing lands, a requirement if they want to label their meat "organic." The animals are never kept on overcrowded feedlots and the calves aren't separated from their mothers unnaturally. A few months ago, White Oak Pastures formed a partnership with Whole Foods and now provides 15 stores in Florida and 19 more throughout the Southeast. Will Harris even built a slaughterhouse on site that complies with the strict requirements of Whole Foods.
Chansky says any Whole Foods meat partner must be USDA inspected, and the grocers bring in third-party inspectors to make sure the free-roaming animals have enough shade, food and water, as well as test any grain for organic certification. Essentially, they look for farmers doing the right thing -- the animal's welfare plays a huge part.
You might notice Whole Foods doesn't sell Harris Family beef as "organic." Although White Oak Pastures is a certified organic farm, they feed their animals non-organic hay during the dry season.
On the health front, grass-fed beef is higher in beta carotene, vitamin E, conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), omega fats and iron and has less fat and cholesterol than corn fed. But due to this, Chansky recommends cooking it no more than medium rare to medium. So those who fled beef when it was touted as the evil fat empire can enjoy grass-fed with less guilt.
For now, they don't have a partner for humanely-treated chickens but they're about four months away from announcing a partnership with a Jacksonville-based hog farmer. The problem isn't finding a farm that treats their animals well; it's finding a farm that can handle the huge demand that is welling up. Apparently, it's no longer just about what you eat - it's also about how what you eat lived.
But let's talk flavor. Both Malowski and Chansky fessed up that corn-fed has more flavor due to the higher fat marbling content (the animals don't get as much exercise). And most people were brought up on corn-fed beef so the earthier flavor of grass fed might knock people off kilter. When I tried it, it was a bit tougher (even cooked medium rare) but I felt better eating it. Maybe that saves me some heartburn.
Whole Foods is located at 1548 North Dale Mabry at I-275.
You can buy grass-fed beef online at White Oak Pastures.
Showing 1-6 of 6
I buy from Rosas Farm in Ocala. They are great! Not only do they have grass fed beef, you can also get eggs,chicken, seafood etc. PLUS, you have the whole eat local thing! Very green indeed! Check them out! Al is a Chef and they have a bed and breakfast up there too, although I have never stayed. They are the new age local farmers. http://www.alrosas.com/
You bring up some interesting points. You may recall my anti-hoopla feeling about organic BUT when it comes to the humane treatment of our food supply, well thats another matter. From a flavor standpoint, I would probably buy ground chuck from the grocery for plain burgers just to retain the great flavor but buying brass fed (which I have ordered before online) could certainly be combined with a bit of ground pork for other types of recipes that dont call for rare to medium rare. This may eliminate some of the health benefits of grass fed beef but it certainly encourages buying meat where the animal was well treated. I certainly stand behind that.
Great to hear that Whole Foods is now carrying Will Harris's beef and even better to hear that it's selling out so quickly! A few thoughts based on my experience in trying to find artisan beef producers (grass- or grain-fed). In general I'd say that grass-finish beef producers are less likely to be heavy users of herbicides or pesticides but not all grass-fed beef is raised on un-sprayed pastures, this is something you'll need to check out with each farm or ranch. (If labeled certified organic, then that is something different.) Also, not all grass-fed beef are raised and finished on pasture. Some brands finish the beef in confined spaces of one sort or another (while not ideal, not all feed yards are horrid IMHO). But more importantly, I have found that grass-fed beef - raised, slaughtered, and aged by artisans - tends to have more flavor rather than less, especially if the beef was dry-aged before being ground into burger. If the ground beef is leaner (which is typical but not always the case with grass-fed beef), your not as likely to have juices dripping down your chin but that's not appealing to everyone.
Being a natural meat artisan myself, I still find it quite difficult to understand why people are confused over the issue of grain feeding ruminents. It still amazes me how much marketing controls the consumers knowledge and thought processes regarding the decisions he makes regarding his food. You are exactly right, though, on the issue of keeping up with demand. Grain feeding, confinement lots, and hormones allows commercial meat industry to grow cattle almost twice as fast as pasture raising them.
Great article. We think White Oak Pastures is a wonderful farm as well, as they were one of the first farms to use the Animal Welfare Approved seal. The Animal Welfare Approved program audits and certifies family farms. Our farmers raise their animals with the highest animal welfare standards, outdoors on pasture or range. For more information about the program please visit http://www.AnimalWelfareApproved.org/
So glad the grass-fed industry weighed in on this. Now, if only we could get more distribution of humanely-treated meat.